Sports memorabilia appraisal fairs don’t always turn up terrific pieces of history. More often than not, it’s a box of baseball cards from the 1980s or 90s or a box of souvenir type items that would be better suited for a garage sale than a major auction catalog.
But sometimes…
Heritage Auctions recently opened an office in Chicago and last month, an older man walked in, hoping to learn the value of some old autographs he’d inherited from his father, a sports fan and collector of autographs at a time when the only reason to collect signatures was for fun—not profit.
These weren’t just scraps of papers with obscure names from long ago. The group of 11 signed pieces were first day covers signed by the members of baseball’s 1939 Hall of Fame inaugural class. Among them: two Babe Ruths, Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner, Walter Johnson, Cy Young, Eddie Collins, Nap Lajoie, George Sisler and Grover Alexander. Despite some toning on the 78-year-old stamped envelopes, they had been well-preserved.
The man’s father had attended the Coopertown induction ceremony in 1939 and got some of the envelopes autographed at the time. At least one was apparently signed at a later date as Lajoie dated his signature “2-1-41”.
The collective value of the covers is over $100,000 and they’ll be among the featured items in the Heritage August catalog auction. Here’s a look at some of them:
Related Stories:
Ultimate 1930s TTM Effort Lands Hall of Fame Autographs
1948 Leaf Football Set Sells for $176,299
New Canada Post Goalie Stamps Include Random Autographs, More
Lone Complete Run of MLB All-Star Tickets Could Fetch Six Figures
Photo of the Day: Packers vs Bears 1939
Photo of the Day: Jackie Robinson, Gridiron Star
2nd Casting of Gehrig’s Hall of Fame Plaque Art Discovered
COTW: Aaron Judge Mother’s Day Jersey Could Fetch Big $
80-Year-Old Gehrig Flannel Could Fetch $800,000
Consignment Of The Week: 1913 Marble Slab From Ebbets Field Rotunda
