• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Get Sports Collectors Daily via EMail
    • Advertise with SC Daily
    • Write for Sports Collectors Daily
    • Write About Your Sports Collection
    • Where Can I Sell My Baseball Cards?
  • Hot on eBay
    • Most Watched Graded Rookies
    • Most Watched PSA 10 Cards
    • Most Watched BGS, BVG Cards
    • Most Watched SGC Cards
    • Most Watched CSG,CGC Cards
    • Most Watched Baseball Cards
      • Most Watched 2023 Baseball Cards
      • Most Watched 2022 Baseball Rookie Cards
      • Bowman Chrome Cards
      • Ronald Acuna Jr. Cards
      • Shohei Ohtani Cards
      • Mike Trout Cards
      • Fernando Tatis Jr. Cards
      • Babe Ruth Cards
      • Hank Aaron Cards
      • Jackie Robinson Cards:
      • Mickey Mantle Cards
      • Willie Mays Cards
      • Vintage Baseball Card Sets
      • T206 Cards
    • Most Watched Basketball
      • Top 100 Most Watched Basketball Rookie Cards
      • 100 Hottest 2022-23 NBA Rookie Cards
      • 100 Hottest 2021-22 NBA Rookie Cards
      • 100 Hottest 2020-21 NBA Rookie Cards
      • 100 Hottest 2019-20 NBA Rookie Cards
        • Zion Williamson Rookie Cards
        • Ja Morant Rookie Cards
      • Michael Jordan Cards
      • Kobe Bryant Cards
      • LeBron James Rookie Cards
      • Nikola Jokic Rookie Cards
      • Giannis Antetokounmpo Cards
      • Luka Doncic Rookie Cards
      • Prizm Basketball Cards
      • Panini National Treasures
    • Most Watched Football Cards
      • Most Watched NFL Rookie Cards
      • 2022 NFL Rookie Cards
        • Brock Purdy Rookie Cards
      • 2021 NFL Rookie Cards
      • 2020 NFL Rookie Cards
        • Joe Burrow Rookie Cards
        • Justin Herbert Rookie Cards
        • Jalen Hurts Rookie Cards
      • Josh Allen Rookie Cards
      • Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards
      • Tom Brady Cards
    • Most Watched Hockey Cards
      • Top 100 Most Watched Hockey Rookie Cards
      • Most Watched 2021-22 NHL Rookie Cards
      • Most Watched 2020-21 Rookie Cards
      • Most Watched 2019-20 Rookie Cards
      • Connor McDavid Cards
      • Wayne Gretzky Cards
      • Bobby Orr Cards
    • Most Watched Soccer Cards
    • Most Watched UFC Cards
    • Most Watched Golf Cards
    • Most Watched 1 of 1 Cards
    • Most Watched Racing Cards
    • Top Sports Card Dealers on eBay
    • Most Watched Memorabilia
      • Vintage Sports Memorabilia
    • Vintage Sports Tickets, Stubs
    • Most Watched Autographs
  • Ending Soon on Ebay
    • Baseball Cards
    • Basketball Cards
    • Football Cards
    • Hockey Cards
    • Soccer Cards
    • Golf Cards
    • UFC Cards
  • Top - Ad

Sports Collectors Daily

Sports Collectors Daily

Sports collecting news - Sports cards and sports memorabilia industry news.

When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network. 

  • Sports Memorabilia News
  • Sports Card News
    • Modern Sports Card News
      • New Sports Card Release Calendar
      • Shop Talk
    • Vintage Sports Card News
      • Affordable Vintage Cards, Collectibles
      • Old Baseball Card Sets
      • Old Basketball Card Sets
      • Old Football Card Sets
      • Old Hockey Card Sets
      • Vintage Pack Facts
  • Business/Industry News
    • Sports Memorabilia Business News
    • Sports Memorabilia Industry News
  • Around The Hobby
    • Editor’s Blog
    • David Cycleback’s Identification and Authentication Advice
  • Popular Stories
  • Sell Your Cards
You are here: Home / Business/Industry News / Sports Memorabilia Industry News / Card Doctors Could Face Variety of Legal Trouble If Law Pursues

Card Doctors Could Face Variety of Legal Trouble If Law Pursues

July 8, 2019 By Bob D'Angelo

Issues of trust and legitimacy are the biggest takeaways from the recent scandal over graded sports cards that have been trimmed, recolored or otherwise altered. But is there a legal reckoning to come?

A professor of law at a South Florida university says it’s possible, but cautions it is a difficult process.

“This is the crime to commit,” said Bob Jarvis, who has taught baseball law and sports law at Nova Southeastern University for 32 years. “Especially if you don’t get greedy.”

The dogged work of sleuths on the Blowout Cards message board has revealed a disturbing number of obviously doctored cards. Message boards have been full of examples of before and after photographs of cards that have been bought online. Many were sold through PWCC Marketplace, the hobby’s largest volume sports card auction company, which has been offering refunds to collectors who bought them. PSA said it was conducting its own investigation into the matter.

Letter sent by PWCC to a collector who purchased a card believed to have been altered.

PWCC says it also banned longtime card dealer Gary Moser, who among several dealers accused by collectors of misdeeds.  They include trimming, coloring and cleaning cards with an unknown substance that resulted in physical changes to some of them. In an interview with The New York Times earlier this month, Moser denied the accusations, stating he had “nothing to hide.”

The online forum has been the source for an ongoing, almost daily revelation of cards that have been bought at public auction, removed from their holder, altered, graded again (usually higher), and then sold again without disclosure of those actions. The “work” appears to be generating a substantial profit for those involved in the scheme.  While no charges have been filed yet, it’s a concern to anyone who collects cards, whether they were made this year or over 100 years ago.

Attorney Michael Rainka

Any law enforcement agency investigating such a case would look for a paper trail, according to Michael Rainka of Rainka Law in Jacksonville, Florida.

“They would want to speak with anyone that may have been involved with the sale, even if only remotely involved,” Rainka told SC Daily. “I’m sure they would want to see emails, contracts, or any other written correspondence that would provide insight to any crime that may have been committed, as well as researching prior sales with the same individual or company. While I haven’t handled fraud cases concerning altered cards, many cases involving this type of fraud require some expert testimony regarding any alterations that may have been made to the cards which could have increased the value.”

As we’ve written before, Rainka says transporting fraudulent goods through interstate carriers such as the U.S. Mail, UPS or FedEx would also leave any card doctor exposed to a federal investigation.

Altered cards have long been a topic within the hobby, but so far, there has been no widespread prosecution based strictly on that type of crime.

Bob Jarvis has been a professor of law at Nova Southeastern University in Florida for 32 years.

“We’re only catching a small percentage of these frauds,” said Jarvis, 59, co-author of the 2016 book, Baseball and the Law: Cases and Materials. “And prosecuting them is an even smaller percentage.”

So, why aren’t there more criminal cases against card doctors? The reason in some cases could be money, Jarvis said.

“Federal prosecutors are not really interested until you hit a million dollars,” said Jarvis, who earned his law degree from the University of Pennsylvania in 1983. “You have to have a pretty big number to get their attention, and a million gets their attention.”

The Mastro Auctions case was that kind of a head-turner. The firm’s founder was indicted on fraud charges in July 2012 that was centered on shill bidding but court papers also included the alteration of the Holy Grail of cards, a T206 Honus Wagner. In 2015, Mastro was sentenced to federal prison after he paid a $250,000 fine.

That was a high profile case. Jarvis said many other cases don’t get to court because there is simply not enough money involved.

“On the state level, that depends on the state prosecutor,” Jarvis said. “A prosecutor in Topeka is going to have a different number (that would get their attention) than a prosecutor in San Francisco.”

Perception is also a factor, Jarvis said.

“If you’re an elected prosecutor, you don’t want people to say, ‘You’re not going after murderers, you’re going after guys who alter baseball cards,’” Jarvis said.

State prosecutors handle cases that occur in-state. “Prosecutors ask, ‘How easy is this going to be to prove in court?’” Jarvis said. “There can be too much doubt.

“If I have a case where a card is clearly doctored, it’s not just about dollar value. How much time am I going to have to put into this to get a conviction?”

Rainka believes it’s important to speak up if you have firsthand information or have been a victim.

“State or federal authorities are receptive to any information regarding the ongoing commission of a crime, especially a felony, which this likely is.  I would have to imagine that the final sale price of the altered cards is high, therefore the potential loss to the victim would be greater and likely pique their interest.”

If the issues that seem to be connected to several individuals are somehow related, some collectors have wondered whether it could even be a Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act case.  That, too, could pique the interest of prosecutors.

Jarvis offered some fascinating insight into what drives people to pass off altered cards as legitimate or hold them, listing four scenarios: sales, charitable donations, insurance and even loans.

“I want to sell it. I want to donate it. I want to burn it,” Jarvis said. “And here’s a fourth one: Use the card as collateral for a loan — and if you use it, it’s bank fraud.”

Some unscrupulous collectors may overinflate the price of their collections, and when the cards go up in smoke, fraud can occur.

“To get the card insurance money (illegitimately) is fraud,” Jarvis said. “When I say I lost a $10,000 card when in fact I know it was a $10 card (is fraud).”

While many of the cards identified online in recent months have been valued in the hundreds or thousands of dollars, Jarvis said savvy card doctors can turn big profits while remaining under the radar.

“This is highly, highly lucrative,” Jarvis said. “Let’s be honest. If I take a $10 card and alter it so I can sell it for $50, well, if I get caught it’s just a slap on the wrist. People who are stupid try to do the big stuff.”

Slipping cards past a third party grader who renders them authentic with a certain grade doesn’t mean the card doctor is off the hook, either.

“The party altering the card is still liable, both civilly and criminally,” Rainka said.  “The grading company would likely only be subject to criminal liability if it is shown they knew of the alterations prior to accepting the card or were otherwise engaged in a conspiracy with the party making the alterations.”

The authentication services base their reputations on fair, accurate grading, and knowing how the recent alterations have somehow slipped passed graders is something they’re hopefully trying to figure out.

Andy Broome, the senior vintage card grader at Beckett Grading Services, told Forbes that trimming cards was the “worst alteration” the company deals with.

“No card is immune from it, from prewar to the latest Bowman Chrome,” Broome stated.

When customers submit cards for authentication, they fill out paperwork and sign an agreement, such as this one from PSA, that essentially indicates they’re acting in good faith regarding their knowledge of the card.  If they’re found to have violated that agreement, it could open the door for grading companies to take their own legal action.

“The grading company would likely be able to sue the individual making these alterations for fraud,” Rainka stated.  “Even if the company reimburses those would have purchased the altered cards, they would still likely have a very strong case against the individual providing them the card.”

Litigation may be something that authentication companies may try to avoid, though, and cost has nothing to do with it, Jarvis said.

“There’s that embarrassment factor that ‘We got duped,’” Jarvis said. “As soon as you file in court, everyone is going to know you got duped because court filings are public record.”

The red-face factor also applies to collectors.

“When you are duping your victims, a lot of them don’t follow through to prosecute cases because they don’t want to look like idiots,” Jarvis said.

Still, there is legal precedent for prosecuting fraud in the hobby.

In the late 1990s, an 18-month FBI investigation dubbed “Operation Foul Ball” led to the arrest of Anthony J. Alyinovich of Chicago, who crafted a scheme to distribute forged sports memorabilia, focusing on stars such as Michael Jordan. It played into the hands of eager collectors who wanted a piece of their sports heroes.

“When it comes to sports memorabilia, people suspend the skepticism they bring to ordinary affairs of life,” U.S. Attorney David Rosenbloom told Forbes. “If somebody gave you a $50 check signed by Michael Jordan, you would call the bank. But (if someone charged you) $900 for a jersey, (you’d say) ‘Thank you!’”

Another interesting case was Gentry v. eBay, Inc.

Plaintiffs Lars Gentry, Henry Camp, Mike Hyder, James Conboy, William Pommerening and Michael Osacky brought a $100 million class-action lawsuit against eBay, alleging the company “was not doing enough to prevent fakes,” Jarvis said.

The plaintiffs alleged eBay violated California’s Autographed Sports Memorabilia statute by failing to furnish a certificate of authenticity to people who bought autographed items through its website.

“eBay’s defense was ‘We are just a platform,” Jarvis said.

The trial court agreed, ruling eBay was not a dealer. The case was appealed, but the courts upheld the lower court decision in 2002.

If the case had not gone eBay’s way, “they would have gone out of business,” Jarvis said.

Jarvis, like many experts, urges collectors to do research and conduct due diligence before buying any significant piece of memorabilia. For every legitimate dealer, some unscrupulous people are looking for an easy mark and will execute any number of schemes to take your money, including making cards look better than they really are.

“The list of possibilities is only limited to the imagination of the criminal,” he said.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Reddit
  • Facebook Messenger

Related Stories:

Editor’s Blog: More Altered Cards Outed But No Legal Action Yet Altered Cards Update: Pre-War HOFers Impacted Card Alteration Probe Hits USA Today Collectors to Washington Post: We’ve Talked to FBI Notes on the Card Doctoring Scandal Editor’s Blog: List of Doctored Cards Grows; Today Show on MLB Authentication, More PWCC: “Working with Law Enforcement, PSA” on Trimmed, Altered Cards Editor’s Blog: Online Tools, Dogged Collectors Put Focus on Card Makeovers

About Bob D'Angelo

Bob has been a sportswriter and copy editor for more than 35 years and a blogger for a decade. He is celebrating his 50th year of card collecting, and still counts his 1965 Topps Mickey Mantle as his favorite. You can reach him at [email protected].

Filed Under: Popular Stories, Sports Memorabilia Industry News Tagged With: altered cards, Baseball and the Law, Bill Mastro, Bob Jarvis, Card altering scandal, card doctors, coloring

Primary Sidebar

Our articles may contain affiliate links. When you click on links to merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network. 

Shop Sports Cards on Ebay
  • Football
  • Basketball
  • Baseball
  • Hockey

High End Cards and Memorabilia

  • BBCE Authenticated Boxes, Packs opens in a new window
  • Graded pre-War Card eBay Auctions
  • PWCC Premier Auction
  • PWCC Fixed Price Marketplace
  • Graded Rookie Cards on eBay opens in a new window
  • Authenticated Photos on eBay opens in a new window
  • Graded Tickets & Stubs opens in a new window

Bargain Corner

  • Michael Jordan cards $5 and less opens in a new window
  • Kobe Bryant cards $5 and less opens in a new window
  • Mickey Mantle Cards Under $150 opens in a new window
  • Graded T206 Cards Under $150 opens in a new window
  • Pre-War Cards Under $100 opens in a new window
  • Pre-1980 Graded Baseball Cards $10 and Less opens in a new window
  • Pre-1980 Graded Football Cards $10 and Less opens in a new window
  • Vintage Graded Basketball Cards $25 and less opens in a new window
  • Vintage Graded Hockey Cards $10 and Less opens in a new window
  • Complete Sets $20 and Less opens in a new window
  • Baseball Hall of Famers for $5 or Less opens in a new window
  • Football Hall of Famers for $5 or Less opens in a new window
  • Hobby Boxes Under $30 opens in a new window
  • Pre-1986 Rookie Cards Under $1 opens in a new window
  • Buy Boxes Directly from Topps opens in a new window

RSS Auction Report

  • Consignments Wanted – Meet Huggins & Scott at the Philly Show This Weekend
  • Heritage Auctions Icons Photography Auction Ends October 12, 2023
  • Steve Novella Offers PSA Baseball, Football & Non-Sport Cards Auction Ending Sept. 28, 2023

Footer

Categories

  • Around the Hobby
  • Business/Industry News
    • Sports Memorabilia Business News
    • Sports Memorabilia Industry News
  • David Cycleback's Identification and Authentication Advice
  • Editor's Blog
  • Featured Articles
  • Hobby Shop Talk
  • National Sports Collectors Convention
  • Popular Stories
  • Rich Klein's Ramblings
  • Sports Card News
    • Modern Sports Card News
      • New Sports Card Release Calendar
    • Vintage Sports Card News
      • Old Baseball Card Sets
      • Old Basketball Card Sets
      • Old Football Card Sets
      • Old Hockey Card Sets
      • Vintage Pack Facts
  • Sports Memorabilia News
  • Uncategorized

Sponsor Links

  • Sports Card Forumopens in a new window
  • Buying Vintage Sports Cardsopens in a new window
  • Game Used Jerseysopens in a new window
  • Championship Rings For Saleopens in a new window
  • Vintage Basketball Cardsopens in a new window
  • NBA Signed Itemsopens in a new window
  • Autographed Baseballsopens in a new window
  • NASCAR Autographsopens in a new window
  • Vintage Graded Baseball Cardsopens in a new window
  • Player Picturesopens in a new window
  • Vintage Football Cardsopens in a new window
  • Sports Collectors Storeopens in a new window

Pages

Ending on eBay Soon
  • Baseball Card Auctions on eBay Ending Soon
  • Basketball Card Auctions on eBay Ending Soon
  • Football Card Auctions on eBay Ending Soon
  • Hockey Card Auctions Ending Soon on eBay
  • Vintage Sports Memorabilia on eBay Ending Soon
Top 100 on Ebay
  • Top 100 Most Watched Baseball Rookie Cards on eBay
  • Top 100 Most Watched Basketball Rookie Cards for Sale on eBay
  • Top 100 Most Watched Hockey Rookie Card Auctions
  • Top Authenticated Vintage Unopened Sports Card Boxes, Packs on eBay
Most Watched on eBay
  • 100 Most Watched Graded Rookie Cards for Sale on eBay
  • 100 Most Watched Tom Brady Card Auctions on eBay
  • 50 Hottest Hobby Boxes at Auction on eBay
  • 50 Most Watched Golf Trading Cards on eBay
  • 50 Most Watched Wrestling Trading Cards on eBay
  • 75 Most Watched Bowman Chrome Cards
  • Most Popular Bobbleheads on eBay
  • Most Watched 1/1 Cards on eBay
  • Most Watched Basketball Cards on eBay
  • Most Watched Complete Baseball Card Sets at Auction on eBay
  • Most Watched Football Cards on eBay
  • Most Watched Football Rookie Card Auctions
  • Most Watched Goudey Baseball Cards on eBay
  • Most Watched Hockey Cards on eBay
  • Most Watched Racing Cards on eBay
  • Most Watched Soccer Cards for Sale on eBay
  • Most Watched Sports Autographs on eBay
  • Most Watched Sports Jerseys on eBay
  • Most Watched Unopened Sports Card Boxes, Packs on eBay
  • Most Watched Vintage Sports Memorabilia on eBay
  • Hottest Panini National Treasures Cards on eBay
  • Hottest PSA 10 Cards for Sale on eBay
  • What’s Hot on eBay
Sports Memorabilia
  • Sports Card Bargain Bin
  • Sports Memorabilia Auctions Ending Soon on eBay
About Sports Collectors Daily
  • Advertise with SC Daily
  • Contact Us
  • Get Sports Collectors Daily via EMail
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Sell Your Cards
  • What’s It Worth
  • Where Can I Sell My Baseball Cards?

Copyright © 2023 SportsCollectorsDaily.com | Web Design by Wickam Groupopens in a new window